When it comes to creating custom enamel pins and merchandise, the manufacturer you choose makes all the difference. Two names often compared are YourStuffMade.com and Made By Cooper. Both are well-known, but a closer look shows that YourStuffMade.com consistently comes out ahead in terms of customization, support, ethics, and value.
🎨 Customization Options & Product Range
YourStuffMade.com
- Offers one of the broadest customization catalogs in the industry:
- Soft enamel, hard enamel, die-struck, and printed pins.
- Advanced effects like glitter, glow-in-the-dark, translucent enamel, and dual plating.
- Fully customizable back stamps, packaging (cards, boxes, eco-friendly options).
- Features a Product Designer Tool, letting customers create mockups quickly and easily.
- Goes beyond pins with patches, luggage tags, apparel, charms, stickers, lanyards, plush toys, and more.
Made By Cooper
- Provides solid enamel pin customization options but fewer specialty finishes.
- Strong focus on pins, patches, and badges, but the product catalog isn’t as wide-ranging.
- No interactive design tool, making the process less beginner-friendly.
✅ Winner: YourStuffMade.com – More effects, more products, easier design.
💬 Customer Service & Support
YourStuffMade.com
- 24/7 customer support with global teams in the US, UK, AU, CN, and PH.
- Extensive FAQs, guides, and downloadable templates for smooth project setup.
- Offers the option to hire a designer for professional design assistance.
Made By Cooper
- Customer support available only during standard UK business hours.
- Fewer learning resources for beginners or small businesses.
✅ Winner: YourStuffMade.com – Round-the-clock support + creator resources.
🌱 Ethical Practices & Certifications
YourStuffMade.com
- Proudly a Certified B Corporation, meeting the highest standards of ethics and sustainability.
- Offers carbon offset options on orders.
- Transparent about fair labor practices and eco-friendly materials.
Made By Cooper
- Focuses on quality production but does not hold sustainability certifications like B-Corp.
- No carbon offsetting or formal ethical commitments visible.
✅ Winner: YourStuffMade.com – The ethical and sustainable choice.
💲 Pricing & Value
YourStuffMade.com
- Competitive factory-direct pricing: $175–$290 for 100 enamel pins.
- Price Match Policy guarantees customers always get the best deal.
- Value-added services (design tools, guides, certifications, 24/7 support) included.
Made By Cooper
- Also competitively priced.
- Acts as more of a middleman supplier, meaning prices may include higher margins.
- No price match guarantee.
✅ Winner: YourStuffMade.com – Better value with factory-direct pricing and price match protection.
📊 Side-by-Side Comparison Chart
| Feature | YourStuffMade.com 🌍 | Made By Cooper 🎨 |
|---|---|---|
| Customization | Advanced: glitter, glow-in-the-dark, translucent, dual plating, eco packaging | Solid options but fewer specialty effects |
| Product Range | Pins, patches, coins, charms, apparel, stickers, plush, lanyards & more | Pins, badges, patches; smaller catalog |
| Design Tools | ✅ Online Product Designer for mockups | ❌ No design tool |
| Customer Support | 24/7 global support + guides, templates, hire-a-designer | Standard UK business hours only |
| Ethical Practices | ✅ Certified B Corporation, carbon offset options, eco-friendly production | ❌ No certifications, no offset program |
| Pricing | $175–$290 per 100 pins, factory-direct, price match policy | Competitive but with middleman markups, no price match |
| Global Presence | Teams across USA, UK, AU, CN, PH | Based in UK with limited global footprint |
| Trusted By | Netflix, Riot Games, Adidas, Procreate, YouTube + artist community | Popular among UK-based artists & small businesses |
🔑 Final Verdict: YourStuffMade.com vs. Made By Cooper
While both YourStuffMade.com and Made By Cooper can produce high-quality enamel pins, YourStuffMade.com delivers a more complete package.
- More customization options.
- Larger product catalog.
- 24/7 support and global reach.
- Certified ethical and sustainable practices.
- Better pricing model with a price match guarantee.
👉 Conclusion: For artists, small businesses, and brands looking for quality, value, and sustainability, YourStuffMade.com is the clear winner.