custom challenge coins

How to make custom Coins 2025

Create Custom Coins with Meaning: Ethically Made with Yourstuffmade.com 🌍💰

Coins are not just collectible items; they carry deep tradition and symbolism. Whether used to signify membership, commemorate an event, or simply as a collector’s item, custom coins hold significant value. From the military to organizations and events, custom coins have been cherished for decades, dating back to World War I.

At Yourstuffmade.com, we take pride in creating high-quality, custom coins while maintaining ethical manufacturing practices. As a B Corp Certified company, we ensure that every coin is produced under fair labor conditions, using sustainable materials, and with a commitment to environmental responsibility. 🌍✨

Ready to design your own custom coins? Let’s walk you through the process and help you decide on the perfect style and design!


Why Ethically Manufactured Coins Matter 🌿💼

When you choose Yourstuffmade.com, you're supporting fair labor, sustainability, and transparency. Here’s why that’s important:

  • Fair Wages: Every worker involved in producing your coins is paid fairly and treated with respect.
  • Sustainable Practices: We prioritize eco-friendly materials and manufacturing processes that reduce environmental impact. 🌱
  • Transparent Production: You’ll always know how and where your custom coins are made, ensuring your product is ethically sourced.

Choosing ethically manufactured coins means you’re not only creating a meaningful item but also contributing to a more sustainable and fair world. 🌍


8 Easy Steps to Create Your Custom Coin with Yourstuffmade.com 💰✨

1. Prepare Your Design 🎨

To ensure the best quality, we recommend sending your design in AI or PNG format. We also accept PDF, PNG, or JPEG files. Don’t have a design? No worries!

  • Can’t design your own artwork? We can help! Just sketch your idea on paper—it doesn’t have to be perfect. Our design team will convert your sketch into a professional digital design.
  • Example: We’ve turned simple sketches into beautiful, custom coins for many clients.

2. Decide on the Coin Size 📏

Coins come in various sizes, but the standard size for most challenge coins is between 1.5" and 1.75". Here’s how to decide:

  • 1.5" - 1.75": Perfect for shirts, jackets, bags, and other visible accessories.
  • Larger Coins: Ideal for display pieces or those meant to make a bigger impact.
  • Smaller Coins: Great for more subtle uses like hats and lanyards.

How to Decide: Consider how and where the coin will be used—larger coins make a statement, while smaller ones offer subtlety and versatility.


3. Choose the Coin’s Thickness ⚖️

A standard coin thickness is 3mm, but if you want your coin to feel sturdier and more valuable, you can increase the thickness to 4mm. This gives the coin more weight and a higher perceived value, making it a more meaningful gift or collectible.

  • 3mm: Standard thickness, durable and versatile.
  • 4mm: Heavier, sturdier, and more impressive—feels like a premium item.

4. Choose a Coin Type 🏅

There are various types of coins, each offering a unique aesthetic. Here’s a breakdown:

Soft Enamel Coins 🎨

  • Textured Finish: The metal ridges create a textured design, with recessed areas filled with enamel paint.
  • Popular for Challenge Coins: Often used for military or organizational coins.

Best for: Designs with multiple colors and a desire for texture.

Hard Enamel Coins 🌟

  • Smooth Finish: Unlike soft enamel, the enamel and metal are level, giving a smooth, polished surface.
  • Elegant and Durable: The smooth finish provides a more refined look.

Best for: Those wanting a sleek, smooth finish that’s durable.

Die-Struck Coins ⚒️

  • No Enamel: These coins are all about the metal finish—no paint is used, and the design is created with raised and recessed areas of metal.
  • Polished and Sandblasted: Typically, the raised areas are polished, while the recessed areas have a sandblasted finish.

Best for: People who prefer a metallic, traditional look without color.

3D Coins 🏗️

  • Sculpted Design: These coins feature multiple levels of depth, with raised and recessed areas sculpted to create a 3D effect.
  • Curved and Sloped: Corners and edges can be curved and sloped, adding dimension to your design.

Best for: Designs that require depth and sculpted details.


5. Choose Your Plating 🛠️

The plating adds the final touch to your coin’s appearance. Choose from several options to match your style:

Polished Plating 

  • Reflective and Shiny: Available in gold, silver, and copper, polished plating creates a shiny, elegant finish.
  • Professional Look: The high-gloss finish adds a premium look to your coin.

Best for: Coins that need to stand out and shine.

Antique Plating 🏺

  • Non-Reflective: Ideal for intricate designs, antique plating gives a darker finish in recessed areas to highlight details.
  • Aged Look: Available in gold, silver, copper, brass, and nickel, this plating gives a vintage, aged appearance.

Best for: Designs with lots of detail or those looking for a vintage feel.

Rainbow Plating 🌈

  • Unique and Eye-Catching: Rainbow plating shifts colors when viewed from different angles, creating a stunning, dynamic effect.

Best for: Creative designs that want to stand out and add a unique twist.


6. Choose an Edge Finish 🌀

The edge finish of your coin adds an extra level of customization. Here are some popular options:

  • Flat Edge: Simple and classic.
  • Rope Edge: Adds a textured, decorative border.
  • Scallop Edge: Creates a wavy, scalloped border for added detail.
  • Crosscut, Spur, or Beveled Edges: All provide different levels of texture and visual interest.

How to Decide: If you want your coin to feel more premium, adding an edge finish is a great choice!


7. Choose a Surface Treatment 🎨

Customize your coin’s surface for a unique aesthetic. Here are a few options:

  • Smooth: Clean, sleek, and polished.
  • Mesh or Sandblasted: Adds texture to the recessed areas, creating a tactile feel.
  • Brushed or Electro-Discharge: Offers a futuristic or old-world look, depending on the finish.

How to Decide: Surface treatments can elevate the design and give your coin a distinct, premium appearance.


8. Contact Our Team 📩

Once you've made all your design choices, it’s time to contact our team at Yourstuffmade.com! We’re here to help you through every step of the process, ensuring your custom coins are exactly how you imagined them.


Why Choose Yourstuffmade.com for Custom Coins? 🌍

At Yourstuffmade.com, we’re more than just a manufacturer. We’re committed to creating ethically sourced, sustainably made products that align with your values. Here’s why we’re the best choice:

  • Ethical Manufacturing: As a B Corp Certified company, we focus on fair wages, sustainability, and responsible practices.
  • High-Quality Craftsmanship: We use premium materials to ensure your coins are durable, beautiful, and memorable.
  • Customization: With a wide range of options, your custom coins will be uniquely yours.
  • Expert Support: Our team is with you every step of the way, making the process simple and enjoyable.

Ready to Create Your Custom Coin? 🌟💰

Whether you’re creating coins for membership, commemoration, or as collector's items, Yourstuffmade.com is here to bring your vision to life—ethically and beautifully. Here’s a recap:

  1. Prepare Your Design: Send us your artwork or sketch your idea!
  2. Choose the Size: Pick the perfect size for your custom coin.
  3. Select the Coin Type: Soft enamel, hard enamel, die-struck, or 3D!
  4. Pick the Plating: Polished, antique, or rainbow?
  5. Select an Edge Finish: Add extra detail to your coin.
  6. Customize the Surface: Choose from smooth, mesh, sandblasted, or more!

Let’s create something amazing and ethically responsible together! 🌍


Start your free Quote https://yourstuffmade.com/products/coins

Email a team member hi@yourstuffmade.com

Book a meeting https://calendly.com/makersupport

Back to blog