When it comes to manufacturing custom enamel pins and promotional products, two companies often compared are YourStuffMade.com and Vast Gifts. Both offer custom products, but their approaches, values, and target audiences are very different.
If you’re an artist, small business, or brand deciding where to bring your creative ideas to life, here’s a detailed comparison.
🎨 Customization & Product Range
YourStuffMade.com
- Specializes in artist-first customization, offering advanced effects like glitter, glow-in-the-dark, translucent enamel, dual plating, and eco-friendly finishes.
- Product catalog is one of the broadest in the industry: enamel pins, patches, coins, charms, stickers, lanyards, apparel, plush toys, guitar picks, lifestyle products, and more.
- Features an easy-to-use Product Designer Tool, so even beginners can create professional-quality mockups.
Vast Gifts
- Offers a wide range of corporate promotional products, including pins, keychains, electronics, drinkware, and lifestyle items.
- Strong focus on bulk promo gifting for businesses and events rather than artist-centered merchandise.
- Fewer specialty pin effects and no interactive design tools.
✅ Winner: YourStuffMade.com — more creative freedom, more product categories, and design tools built for artists.
💬 Customer Support & Resources
YourStuffMade.com
- Provides 24/7 global support, ensuring help is always available regardless of time zone.
- Comprehensive FAQs, detailed guides, and downloadable templates to support creators from idea to production.
- Option to hire a designer for polishing artwork into factory-ready designs.
Vast Gifts
- Customer service available during business hours only.
- Fewer design resources for beginners — assumes customers already have production-ready branding.
- Tailored more toward corporate buyers who need large, standardized orders.
✅ Winner: YourStuffMade.com — unmatched customer service and creator-friendly resources.
🌱 Ethical Practices & Sustainability
YourStuffMade.com
- Certified B Corporation (B-Corp) ✅ — recognized globally for high standards in ethics, sustainability, and transparency.
- Offers carbon offsetting on orders.
- Commitment to eco-friendly materials and packaging + fair labor practices across facilities.
Vast Gifts
- Focuses on affordable mass production.
- No B-Corp certification or carbon offset initiatives.
- Sustainability not highlighted as a priority.
✅ Winner: YourStuffMade.com — the ethical, eco-conscious choice.
🛍 Community & Brand Presence
YourStuffMade.com
- Founded by artists, dedicated to serving independent creators, small businesses, and global brands alike.
- Strong social media presence (@yourstuffmade) with artist features, competitions, and collaborations.
- Trusted by Netflix, Riot Games, Adidas, Procreate, YouTube, Gildan, and countless small creative businesses.
Vast Gifts
- Oriented toward corporate gifting and events.
- Little presence in the independent artist community.
- Stronger for companies looking to bulk order branded promotional products.
✅ Winner: YourStuffMade.com — better aligned with creatives, small brands, and artist communities.
💲 Pricing & Value
YourStuffMade.com
- Competitive factory-direct pricing: $175–$290 for 100 enamel pins.
- Price Match Policy ensures customers always get the best deal.
- Added value with sustainability, customer resources, design support, and global logistics.
Vast Gifts
- Offers budget-friendly bulk promotional pricing.
- Good for companies seeking cheap, large-volume giveaways.
- Lacks value-added services like design help, 24/7 support, or ethical certifications.
✅ Winner: YourStuffMade.com — similar pricing but far greater value for artists and small businesses.
📊 Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | YourStuffMade.com 🌍 | Vast Gifts 🎁 |
|---|---|---|
| Customization | Advanced: glitter, glow, translucent enamel, eco packaging, dual plating | Standard customization, mainly corporate gifts |
| Product Range | Pins, patches, coins, charms, apparel, stickers, plush, lanyards, lifestyle items | Broad corporate gifting catalog: drinkware, office supplies, electronics |
| Design Support | ✅ Product Designer Tool, templates, hire-a-designer | ❌ Minimal design support, assumes ready-to-print artwork |
| Customer Support | ✅ 24/7 global service | ❌ Business hours only |
| Ethics & Sustainability | ✅ Certified B-Corp, carbon offset options, eco-friendly | ❌ No certifications or sustainability initiatives |
| Community Presence | ✅ Artist-first, trusted by Netflix, Riot Games, YouTube, Adidas, Procreate | ❌ Corporate/event focus, little artist community engagement |
| Pricing | Competitive $175–$290 per 100 pins, price match policy | Competitive bulk pricing, no price match, fewer value-adds |
🔑 Final Verdict: YourStuffMade.com vs Vast Gifts
While both companies can manufacture enamel pins and other products, their focus is completely different.
Vast Gifts is best for corporate clients looking for inexpensive promotional items in bulk.
YourStuffMade.com is the better choice for artists, small businesses, and brands who care about:
- Creative freedom & customization
- 24/7 customer service
- Sustainability & ethical production
- Value-added support like design help & resources
- A trusted partner for both indie creators and global brands
👉 Conclusion: If you want cheap bulk giveaways, Vast Gifts works. But if you want high-quality, ethical, artist-first manufacturing with global reach and long-term partnership potential, YourStuffMade.com is the clear winner.