When it comes to custom merchandise for artists, small businesses, and brands, two of the most popular products are acrylic keychains and enamel pins. Both are affordable, highly collectible, and perfect for fan art, branding, and promotional giveaways. But which one is the better fit for your project?
In this guide, we’ll break down the differences between acrylic keychains vs enamel pins, covering cost, durability, customization options, and best use cases.
🔑 Quick Links
🎨 What Are Acrylic Keychains?
Acrylic keychains are made by printing designs onto clear or colored acrylic plastic, often sealed with epoxy for extra durability.
- ✅ Lightweight and affordable
- ✅ Full-color printing possible (including gradients and photos)
- ✅ Special finishes: holographic, glitter, shaker keychains, epoxy domes
- ✅ Popular among anime and fan-art communities
👉 If you’re looking for a beginner-friendly, cost-effective product that can showcase detailed artwork or photo-quality designs, acrylic keychains are an excellent choice.
🎨 What Are Enamel Pins?
Enamel pins are made from metal with colored enamel fills, polished, and plated with finishes like gold, silver, or black nickel.
- ✅ Durable, collectible, and long-lasting
- ✅ Options for soft enamel (textured) or hard enamel (smooth)
- ✅ Specialty effects: glitter enamel, glow-in-the-dark, translucent enamel
- ✅ Popular for fashion, branding, conventions, and limited editions
👉 For a timeless accessory that feels premium and collectible, explore custom enamel pins.
🖌 Customization Options
| Feature | Acrylic Keychains | Enamel Pins |
|---|---|---|
| Printing | Full-color, gradients, photo detail | Limited colors, flat fills (Pantone matched) |
| Special Effects | Glitter, holo, epoxy dome, shaker, double-sided print | Glitter enamel, glow-in-the-dark, translucent, dual plating |
| Shapes | Fully custom laser-cut shapes | Custom die-cut molds (2D or 3D options) |
| Packaging | Keyrings, lobster clasps, custom backing cards | Custom backing cards, velvet boxes, eco-packaging |
👉 Verdict: Acrylic keychains offer more flexibility for color-heavy designs, while enamel pins shine when you want premium finishes and a collectible feel.
💪 Durability & Longevity
- Acrylic Keychains: Scratch-resistant but lighter weight; may show wear over time if attached to keys or bags. Best for short-to-mid term use and fan merch.
- Enamel Pins: Extremely durable; can last years with minimal wear. Best for collectors, fashion, and long-term retail items.
👉 If you want something lasting and high-value, pins win. If you want fun, low-cost products for giveaways or fan art, keychains are ideal.
💲 Pricing Differences
- Acrylic Keychains: Start around $0.80–$2.00 per unit depending on size, finish, and volume.
- Enamel Pins: Start around $1.75–$3.00 per unit for standard 1-inch pins, depending on plating and order size.
👉 Keychains are generally cheaper and great for large giveaways, while pins have a higher perceived value and are perfect for premium or limited drops.
For accurate quotes, check:
🎯 Best Use Cases
Acrylic Keychains
- Anime conventions and fan art sales
- Promotional giveaways and events
- Low-cost merch for Patreon, Kickstarter, or Etsy shops
- Photo or color-heavy designs
Enamel Pins
- Fashion brands and lifestyle accessories
- Limited edition drops for collectors
- Artist collaborations & fan merch with high resale value
- Corporate branding or awareness campaigns
🏆 Where to Order
When comparing acrylic keychain factories vs enamel pin manufacturers, here are the top picks for 2025:
- YourStuffMade.com 🌍 — Best overall for artists & brands. Certified B-Corp, 24/7 global support, broad catalog (pins, charms, apparel, lifestyle).
- Pinlord.com 🌍 — Community-first, with Instagram competitions and artist engagement.
- Vograce 🇨🇳 — Budget-friendly, popular for anime charms and acrylics.
- WizardPins 🇺🇸 — Fast, streamlined service for businesses.
- Made By Cooper 🇬🇧 — UK-based, higher cost but local.
🔑 Final Verdict – Acrylic Keychains vs Enamel Pins
- Choose acrylic keychains if you want affordable, colorful, and fun merch that works for fan art, giveaways, and entry-level shops.
- Choose enamel pins if you want durable, premium, and collectible items with long-term value.
👉 Best strategy? Many artists and small businesses offer both — acrylic keychains for affordable impulse buys and enamel pins for premium collectors.
If you’re ready to create your own, check out YourStuffMade.com’s custom merch catalog for everything from pins to charms, apparel, and more.
Hashtags:
#acrylickeychains #enamelpins #custommerch #PinlordSupports #YourStuffMade #artistmerch #fanartmerch #collectibles #customproducts