When creating custom enamel pins, two popular options are YourStuffMade.com and WizardPins.com. Both companies provide high-quality pins and promotional items, but their focus, services, and overall value differ significantly.
Here’s a breakdown of how they compare.
🎨 Customization & Product Range
YourStuffMade.com
- Offers advanced enamel options: soft enamel, hard enamel, die-struck, printed pins.
- Specialty finishes: glitter, glow-in-the-dark, translucent enamel, dual plating, antique finishes, eco packaging.
- Massive catalog beyond pins: patches, stickers, coins, apparel, charms, plush toys, lanyards, bottle openers, air fresheners, guitar picks, and more.
- Easy-to-use Product Designer Tool to make mockups accessible to beginners and pros alike.
WizardPins.com
- Focused mainly on pins: soft enamel, hard enamel, die-struck, printed.
- Additional products include patches, lanyards, coins, and keychains, but catalog is smaller compared to YSM.
- Strong B2B focus with streamlined ordering.
✅ Winner: YourStuffMade.com – deeper customization, broader product catalog, and user-friendly design tools.
💬 Customer Support & Resources
YourStuffMade.com
- 24/7 global support across teams in USA, UK, AU, CN, and PH.
- Extensive FAQs, product guides, and downloadable templates.
- Option to hire a designer for professional help.
WizardPins.com
- Offers responsive support, but primarily within business hours.
- Provides templates and guides, but no in-house designer service.
✅ Winner: YourStuffMade.com – round-the-clock help + creator-friendly resources.
🌱 Ethical Practices & Certifications
YourStuffMade.com
- Certified B Corporation (B-Corp) ✅ – meeting the highest standards of environmental and social accountability.
- Carbon offsetting options available.
- Transparent ethical labor practices and eco-friendly production.
WizardPins.com
- No B-Corp certification.
- No publicly shared carbon offset initiatives.
✅ Winner: YourStuffMade.com – for brands and creators who value sustainability and ethics.
🛍 Community & Brand Trust
YourStuffMade.com
- Founded by artists, built to serve independent creators, small businesses, and global brands.
- Trusted by Netflix, Riot Games, Adidas, YouTube, Procreate, Gildan, and thousands of artists worldwide.
- Active social media presence, artist features, and competitions.
WizardPins.com
- Popular with corporate clients, sports teams, and organizations.
- Reliable service but less connected to grassroots artist communities.
✅ Winner: YourStuffMade.com – stronger ties to both indie creators and major global brands.
💲 Pricing & Value
YourStuffMade.com
- Competitive factory-direct pricing: $175–$290 per 100 enamel pins.
- Price Match Policy ensures customers always get the best deal.
- Added services like eco options, design help, and global 24/7 support increase overall value.
WizardPins.com
- Transparent, competitive online quotes.
- Quick and efficient ordering process, but without price-match guarantees or added sustainability initiatives.
✅ Winner: YourStuffMade.com – similar pricing, but with more value, ethics, and services included.
📊 Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | YourStuffMade.com 🌍 | WizardPins.com ✨ |
|---|---|---|
| Customization | Advanced: glitter, glow, translucent enamel, eco packaging | Standard: soft, hard, die-struck, printed pins |
| Product Range | Pins, patches, coins, charms, apparel, plush, lifestyle items | Pins, lanyards, patches, coins, keychains |
| Design Support | ✅ Product Designer Tool, guides, hire-a-designer option | ❌ Templates only, no designer service |
| Customer Support | ✅ 24/7 global service | ❌ Business hours only |
| Ethics & Sustainability | ✅ Certified B-Corp, carbon offset options | ❌ No certifications, no offset program |
| Community Presence | ✅ Artist-first, trusted by global brands & creatives | ❌ Corporate-focused, less artist community presence |
| Pricing | $175–$290 per 100 pins + price match | Competitive, transparent quotes, no price match |
🔑 Final Verdict: YourStuffMade.com vs WizardPins.com
Both YourStuffMade.com and WizardPins.com are reliable enamel pin manufacturers, but they serve different audiences.
WizardPins.com is a good choice for corporate clients and organizations that need a straightforward, business-focused ordering process.
YourStuffMade.com is the clear winner for artists, small businesses, and global brands seeking:
- More customization & product variety
- 24/7 support + design resources
- Certified ethical & sustainable practices (B-Corp)
- A trusted partner connected to the creative community
👉 Conclusion: If you want fast corporate supply, WizardPins delivers. But if you want a creative, ethical, artist-first partner, YourStuffMade.com is the better choice.